Prebiotics: what you need to know

With just one different letter separating prebiotics and probiotics, no wonder they get confused! To muddy the waters even further, they both have the same “purpose”, namely, to balance our microbiota and improve our health. But they are really quite different, both in terms of their nature and how they work. As relative newcomers, prebiotics are still not well understood by consumers. What are they? Where can you get them? Why are they good for you? It’s time to take stock and set matters straight!

Created 16 October 2020
Updated 04 June 2024
Prébiotiques

About this article

Created 16 October 2020
Updated 04 June 2024

Table of contents

Table of contents

What is a prebiotic?

The first “official” definition of prebiotics was suggested back in 1995. Since then, it has evolved based on breakthroughs in our understanding of the role and inner workings of the human microbiota.1,2

A potted history

Prebiotics were defined for the first time in 1995 by two scientists, Glenn Gibson and Marcel Roberfoid.3 They described them as “a nondigestible food ingredient that beneficially affects the host by selectively stimulating the growth and/or activity of one or a limited number of bacteria in the colon, and thus improves host health”. This definition underwent various iterations until 2016, when an international panel of experts came to a consensus on “a substrate selectively used by host microorganisms that confers health benefits”.4 In layman's terms, prebiotics are substances that target specific microorganisms in our microbiota, the beneficial ones, and “feed” them. In doing so, they improve our health. This means that these substrates (foods) are out-of-bounds to the majority of microorganisms in our microbiota,5 especially to bacteria that can make us ill, such as certain species of clostridia and E. coli!6

Some things change, some things stay the same: prebiotics today and tomorrow

According to the 1995 definition, only certain compounds from the carbohydrate family would be classed as prebiotics.7 The word “substrate”, which has recently been preferred by experts, extends the concept of prebiotics beyond carbohydrates to anything that specifically feeds bacteria in the microbiota and thus improves our health.8,9 In addition, prebiotics can work in other areas of the body with a microbiota, not just the intestines. They can support the skin, mouth, and vagina.10 
Neither the first nor the most recent definition specifies which microorganisms are targeted by prebiotics. Historically, these have been bifidobacteria and lactobacilli, known to be beneficial for our health and also used as probiotics.11 They are still the most commonly tested and used as a target for prebiotics. However, we now know that other microorganisms can metabolize prebiotics and contribute to our good health.12 Researchers are turning their attention to prebiotics able to stimulate species such as Propionibacterium, Faecalibacterium, Eubacterium, Akkermansia, and Roseburia.13,14

Requirements for a “prebiotic”

The definition may have been extended,15 but this doesn’t mean any old product can call itself a prebiotic!

Before a product can be classified as prebiotic, its chemical structure must first be clearly described. Preclinical laboratory studies must then be conducted, followed by clinical trials in humans, to confirm:

  • Its resistance to digestive enzymes (e.g., stomach acid and bile) allowing it to reach the target microbiota (e.g., gut microbiota) intact;
  • its selectivity and action on the target microorganisms;
  • how it affects the microbiota and its measurable health benefits;
  • the effective dose with no side effects.16,17,18

Let’s be clear: prebiotics are not…

Fibers
Fibers are indigestible dietary carbohydrates found mainly in plants. They may be fermentable (soluble), such as apple pectin, or non-fermentable (insoluble), such as cellulose and lignin. Soluble fibers are used by microorganisms in the gut, but usually by the majority of them because they do not “selectively” feed only bacteria that are beneficial for our health.19 However, there are some soluble fibers that act only on beneficial bacteria and can therefore be considered prebiotics, meaning that nowadays most prebiotics are fibers. But prebiotics aren't always fibers (such as lactulose), and not all fibers are prebiotics.20,21,22

Probiotics
Probiotics are live microorganisms, which when administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host.23,24 Find out more here!

Sources, functions, mechanism of action... Prebiotics

Find out what prebiotics look like, where to find them, and how they target our beneficial microbes.

Time for some chemistry: what are prebiotics? 

Nowadays, most compounds classified as prebiotics belong to the family of complex carbohydrates: oligosaccharides and polysaccharides.25,26 Oligosaccharides are chains, or polymers, of several simple sugars or monosaccharides (usually between 3 and 10), such as glucose, fructose, and galactose. Polysaccharides contain more than 20;27 However, some of the rarer prebiotics contain only two sugars; these are known as disaccharides.

The main prebiotics are

FOS (including inulin) and GOS are the prebiotics whose effects on the beneficial microbes in our intestinal microbiota and on our health are most scientifically recognized. They are therefore currently the “stars” of the prebiotic world;32,33 The recommended dose for a prebiotic effect in adults is 5-8 g FOS or GOS per day.34

However, other substances are being tested for their prebiotic potential, such as:

  • Other complex carbohydrates (fibers): xylo-oligosaccharides (XOS), isomalto-oligosaccharides (IMO), polydextrose, soybean oligosaccharides (SBOS), beta-glucans, and pectin;
  • Starch derivatives, such as polyols: sorbitol, maltitol, etc.;
  • Polyunsaturated fatty acids; o Polyphenols: such as cocoa and tea.35,36,37,38

GOS for babies!

Breastmilk contains oligosaccharides that feed bifidobacteria and other microbial species that colonize the microbiota of breastfed babies, help develop their immune system and metabolism, and promote good digestion. These human milk oligosaccharides (HMO) are classified as prebiotics.39 Lots of baby formulas also contain prebiotics that mimic HMOs, such as GOS and FOS.40

Where exactly can you find them?

Prebiotics are found naturally in many fruits and vegetables and in breastmilk. They are also added to foods, such as cookies, cereals, drinks, and dairy products, as well as to baby food.41 Finally, they are available as dietary supplements,42 alone or combined with probiotics, vitamins, minerals, or plant extracts, etc.

Natural sources of prebiotics

Many fruits, vegetables, cereals, and other natural foodstuffs contain prebiotics. For example: 

  • Artichokes, chicory root, leeks, asparagus (which contain inulin);
  • Bananas, garlic, onions, honey, wheat (which contain FOS);
  • Soy and oat milk, cashew nuts, lupins, chickpeas, and pistachios (which contain GOS).43,44

These foods contain small quantities of prebiotics and eating them only occasionally will not have any significant effect on your health.45

Our hunter-gatherer ancestors ate lots of foods containing natural prebiotics, consuming up to about 135 g per day. However, this is quite uncommon with our modern Western diets, which usually only provide us with 1-4 g a day in the US, and 3-11 g a day in Europe.46

Prebiotics are now manufactured industrially, either isolated from foods rich in prebiotic substances or made synthetically from sugars, such as fructose, lactose, or sucrose.47,48,49

What are prebiotics for?

Imagine your microbiota like a garden, where prebiotics are the “fertilizer” that help beautiful plants grow taller, but not the pesky weeds! So, the whole body benefits.

Just like fertilizer, prebiotics aren't “essential” for feeding the microbes in our microbiota. But they do stimulate the growth and activity of microorganisms that are beneficial for our health. This means they help rebalance our microbiota, especially by increasing the ratio of beneficial bacteria to pathogenic bacteria, allowing the microbiota to correctly perform its role of digestion, absorption of nutrients, supporting our natural defenses, etc.50,51

During fermentation, prebiotics also help bacteria to produce other substances that help the body and our health.52 For example, they increase the production of lactate and the short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs) acetate, propionate, and butyrate, which act in the intestine and travel around the rest of the body in the bloodstream.53 They are a source of energy for the body and play important roles for our health, such as maintaining the integrity of the intestinal barrier, and regulating the metabolism of sugars and fats.54

Finally, these SCFAs lower the pH in our colon (making it more acidic), which also has health benefits, such as better absorption of nutrients, and more effective protection against microbes.55,56

Philanthropic prebiotics: Selective but not snobs!

Recent studies show that the impact of prebiotics on the microbiota clearly extends much further than their target microorganisms: the byproducts of their transformation stimulate other bacterial species that in turn can benefit other prebiotics.57 This creates a beneficial knock-on effect, where the product of one bacterium feeds another and so on. For example, acetate and lactate, the main metabolites of lactobacilli, can be used by other microorganisms to produce propionate and butyrate.58

How can prebiotics improve our health?

Prebiotics are a relatively new field of science, and there are fewer clinical studies on their health effects than for probiotics.59 However, results suggest that by supporting the growth and metabolism of beneficial bacteria in the microbiota,60 prebiotics contribute to several main essential bodily functions, making it better equipped to combat various situations.61

Dynamic research for uncovering new benefits

Studies are currently under way into other potential health benefits of prebiotics, mainly involving animal models, with promising initial results. For example, prebiotics may help combat the malignant transformation of cells. In fact, their fermentation products, such as butyrate, could provide protection from colorectal cancer. Some prebiotics could also help improve memory and concentration in the elderly, or even slow down cognitive decline in diseases such as Alzheimer’s. Finally, they could lower triglyceride levels in the blood, which would help improve the health of the cardiovascular system. Although there is mounting evidence as to the benefits of prebiotics, much more scientific work is needed before learned societies can release further recommendations as to their use.85,86

Different effects for you and me!

Just like probiotics, prebiotics can affect each person differently. First, their effects depend on the presence of their particular target microorganisms in the person’s microbiota. The effects may also vary in people with microbiota-altering genes or a genetic predisposition to certain diseases. Finally, they may be influenced by individual lifestyle: diet, general health, or even medicine use, etc.87,88 Researchers hope to still further their understanding of how prebiotics affect the microbiota, and of techniques for analyzing the microbiota in individuals in order to develop more accurate and personalized recommendations.89

Recommended by our community

"It's good to know" - Colette Pellerin (From My health, my microbiota)

"Thank you" Editha Villagante (From My Health, my microbiota)

"Thank you" Hazel Walker (From My Health, my microbiota)

"Thank you so much for sharing." - Aline Dover (From My Health, my microbiota)

"Good information always." Elsie Turner (From My Health, my microbiota)

BMI 22.52-Nov 22